Back to the blog

Homeowners overestimating house worth by 1.33 percent

by Kelly Leighton on

The gap between homeowner’s estimates of their home’s worth and appraiser’s estimates has grown for the first time in the past six months.

According to Quicken Loans’ National Home Price Perception Index, on average, the appraiser estimate was 1.33 percent below the owner’s in December.

Prior to December, the gap between the two had been inching closer and closer together. However, Quicken Loans pointed out that home values decreased 1.19 percent from November to December, but rose 3.85 percent compared to December 2015. Yet, year-to-year, home price growth is slowing. From November 2015 to November 2016, home prices increased 5.28 percent.

“Home value growth has been mostly driven by enthusiastic buyers vying for a smaller than usual inventory of properties,” said Quicken Loans Chief Economist Bob Walters. “Appraised values have dipped along with the seasonal decline in sales around the winter months. It’s yet to be seen if value growth will build as sales rise in the spring, or as construction increases.”

In Philadelphia, the only Pennsylvania metro analyzed, homeowners were overestimating the cost of their home by 2.94 percent, compared to what appraisers said it was worth. This is continuing to widen, having only been 2.87 percent in November. However, this is a decrease from December 2015, where homeowners overestimated the value of their home by 3.50 percent. Philadelphia has consistently had one of the largest, if not the largest, gaps between homeowner’s estimates and appraiser’s.

The report also found that homeowners in the West and South areas of the country were more likely to match the appraisers’ opinions or even underestimate their home’s worth, as opposed to homeowners in the Northeast and Midwest, who tended to think their homes were worth more.


Appraisals Appraisers Appraisal Home value Homeowners perception
Comments (2)


  • Richard Smeltz    January 19, 2017 | 7:28 am

    Unless I am reading this incorrectly, a 1.33 variance in value is actually pretty close. If 2 appraisals were done and they were within 2% of each other, that would be considered phenomenal. The writer also uses the terms cost, worth and value interchageably. To the writer they may be the same, to an appraiser/Realtor, there is a difference.

    Reply to Richard Smeltz
    • Kelly Leighton    January 19, 2017 | 8:03 am

      Thanks Richard. The significance of the article is that the gap between homeowners’ estimates and appraisers’ estimates had been closing as of late, but recently, the gap has widened.

      Reply to Kelly Leighton

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.